Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Illegal Disposal topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Environment committee adopts amendment capping cumulative penalties for illegal disposal enforcement
Summary
The House Environment & Agriculture Committee approved changes to the proposed penalty scheme for violations tied to illegal disposal, moving an amendment to cap cumulative penalties relative to the documented costs of cleanup and to allow payment plans without triggering further penalties.
The House Environment & Agriculture Committee voted unanimously to adopt an amendment and advance HB179, a bill that would change enforcement and penalty mechanics for illegal disposal and remediation obligations. The committee adopted Amendment 202503339H, which adjusts the penalty formula so that cumulative penalties cannot exceed 100% of the documented cost of the damage and allows a responsible party to avoid continuing penalties if they enter and remain current on an agreed payment plan.
Representative Comteau moved the OTPA (adopt amendment) motion; Representative Howard seconded. The roll‑call was 13‑0 in favor. Committee members described the amendment as a compromise intended to preserve enforcement incentives while avoiding penalties that could be disproportionate to the underlying remediation cost.
Speakers
- Representative Barbara Comteau (mover of amendment) - Representative Howard (second)
Actions
- kind: other identifiers: {agenda_item_id:"HB179"} motion: "OTPA with adoption of amendment 202503339H (cap cumulative penalties at 100% of documented damage; allow payment plans without further penalty while current)." mover: "Representative Barbara Comteau" second: "Representative Howard" vote_record: [ {member:"Vice Chairwoman Comteau",vote:"yes"},{member:"Representative Potenza",vote:"yes"},{member:"Representative Scully",vote:"yes"},{member:"Representative Barber",vote:"yes"},{member:"Representative Minor",vote:"yes"},{member:"Representative Bixby",vote:"yes"},{member:"Representative Sofakidis",vote:"yes"},{member:"Representative Germana",vote:"yes"},{member:"Representative Haskins",vote:"yes"},{member:"Representative Howard",vote:"yes"},{member:"Representative Gruber",vote:"yes"},{member:"Chairwoman Aaron",vote:"yes"}] tally:{yes:13,no:0,abstain:0} outcome:"approved" legal_threshold:{met:true,notes:"simple majority of committee"}
Why it matters
Sponsors said the amendment preserves an enforcement tool while avoiding financially ruinous cumulative penalties that could exceed the cost of the remediation being enforced. The committee placed the bill on the consent calendar for the next floor filing.
