Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the St Josephs Parcels topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
St. Joseph’s properties drawn into Syracuse exemption review as city questions use of small parcels
Summary
City staff told the Board of Assessment Review they had audited dozens of small, tax‑exempt parcels linked to St. Joseph’s and were seeking evidence that each parcel still supports hospital operations.
City of Syracuse staff told the Board of Assessment Review on Feb. 13 that they had undertaken a targeted review of many small parcels carrying nonprofit exemptions that have historically been associated with St. Joseph’s hospital. Staff said they reviewed “30 or 40” vacant or marginal lots and raised questions about whether the parcels remain actively used to support the hospital’s charitable mission.
What staff said City staff said the review flagged multiple small parcels and vacant slivers of land on inclines that are intermittently used as summer employee parking, equipment staging areas (salt/snow removal) or adjacent green space contiguous to hospital operations. Staff noted that some parcels were long exempt without periodic re‑attestation and that the review aimed to confirm whether each parcel’s current use supports a full exemption.
What St. Joseph’s told the board Representatives for St. Joseph’s acknowledged ownership of several small parcels and said usage varies by parcel. Testimony included these points: - Several lots are used as employee parking in non-winter months and for buildings-and-grounds staging (salt, plows, dumpsters) during operations. - One vacant church property purchased by St. Joseph’s (former First Lutheran at 119 James St.) has been vacant seven years; the hospital described structural problems and asbestos, said a broker opinion placed its value around $230,000 and said a $250,000 system office remediation allocation would address urgent stabilization work before a larger renovation. - For other small parcels near cooling towers and loading docks, St. Joseph’s said the parcels are functionally part of campus operations and therefore should be considered in support of the hospital’s exempt purpose.
Questions and next steps Board members pressed St. Joseph’s on how frequently parcels are used, whether barriers are deployed in winter to prevent unsafe parking and whether parcels are in fact buildable or merely green space. Staff asked for site visits and photographic or documentary evidence proving active operational use. The board did not issue rulings at the hearing; staff said they would visit some sites and that formal notices would be mailed in April.
Why it matters If the board or taxing authorities reclassify previously exempt parcels as taxable, Syracuse’s property tax base could increase and the hospital could face retroactive tax bills for parcels deemed not primarily necessary for exempt charitable operations. St. Joseph’s representatives said they plan phased remediation and requested the board consider ongoing efforts and the hospital’s stated community services in any decision.
Provenance: This article combines the city’s auditing statements and St. Joseph’s responses from the Feb. 13 hearing. The board requested additional documentation and on-site verification; no formal vote was recorded in the transcript.
