Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Charter Schools topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
District staff recommends denying four amended charter applications, conditionally approves KIPP Cordova Collegiate Elementary
Summary
Office of Charter Schools recommended denial of Dreamcatchers, Hillcrest High, Kirby Middle and Still I Rise; recommended approval of KIPP Cordova Collegiate Elementary after amended submission. Staff noted statutory appeals process and new state law that can route repeated overturns to the state commission.
The Office of Charter Schools recommended that the Shelby County Board deny four of five amended charter applications and approve one. At an amended-round review staff recommended denial of Dreamcatchers Charter School, Hillcrest High School, Kirby Middle School and Still I Rise Academy. The office recommended approval of KIPP Cordova Collegiate Elementary after the applicant amended the application and met the Tennessee Department of Education rubric and local policy standards.
Why it matters: Charter approvals create binding 10‑year agreements that shift students and funding. Staff emphasized the fiscal impact to the district at the five‑year midpoint (year five) for each proposed school, and described the state appeals process that allows applicants to appeal denials to the Tennessee Public Charter School Commission.
What staff said: Orlandra Parker of the Office of Charter Schools presented the review, saying the most common reasons for denial in the amended round were incomplete documentation, weaknesses in academic models or past performance, and lack of demonstrated community demand. Parker highlighted that state law (Public Chapter 275, effective July 1) narrows local control in repeated overturn scenarios: if the commission overturns LEA denials three times in three consecutive years, applicants may apply directly to the commission for five years.
Fiscal analysis: Staff presented year‑5 enrollment and estimated district fiscal impact at midpoint: Dreamcatchers ($5.0M), Hillcrest High ($7.1M), KIPP Cordova Collegiate Elementary (~$6.5M), Kirby Middle (~$6.2M), Still I Rise (~$6.1M). Staff said those numbers could increase if a school reaches full approved capacity.
Board reaction and next steps: Members asked how often the state commission overturns LEA denials and whether appeals typically hinge on rubric interpretation or other factors. Parker said the commission upheld LEA decisions more than half the time in recent cycles but that overturns do occur and that two of the last overturned cases involved ASD operators. Trustees asked staff to include clear rationales in board materials so the board’s legal and policy teams can defend decisions if appealed. The district will bring the formal recommendation to the board’s business meeting by the mandated 60‑day deadline (July 29).
