Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Housing Development topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning commission recommends 4‑story, reduced‑commercial plan for 5200 South development
Summary
Roy City Planning Commission voted June 10 to recommend that City Council approve a development agreement allowing Sumaterra Ventures to build a four‑story mixed‑use project at 3423/3443 West and 5200 South with an initial 3,000 square feet of commercial space and 14‑foot floor plates designed for later conversion to retail.
The Roy City Planning Commission on June 10 unanimously recommended City Council approve a development agreement for Sumaterra Ventures that would allow a four‑story mixed‑use building at properties listed in the packet as 3423 and 3443 West, 5200 South.
Sumaterra CEO Mike Watson told the commission the company has several projects in northern Utah and seeks to deliver a “mindful” product for Roy residents. Watson said the proposal would consolidate an earlier two‑building plan into a single development and asked the commission to allow an initial commercial ground floor of 3,000 square feet rather than requiring the entire first floor be commercial. "We're asking for 3,000 square feet, which we feel is a very strong presence for what is available and required and in demand in that area," Watson said. He said the developer also wants to build the main floor with a 14‑foot ceiling so the space can be converted to more commercial area in the future as market demand warrants.
Under the scheme Watson presented, an earlier design showed 104 residential units across two buildings (a three‑story front building with about 32 units and a four‑story rear building with about 72 units). The developer presented an alternate consolidated layout that increases internal amenity area (about 6,700 square feet of tenant amenity space as described in the presentation), moves surface parking away from adjacent neighbor fences and arranges a drive path for emergency access so no parking spaces back directly onto private backyards.
City staff recommended forwarding a positive recommendation to council. Public commenters included resident Kevin Homer, who said he supports efforts to create more housing opportunities in Roy but urged questions be answered before annexation or zoning changes. Commissioners discussed tradeoffs between preserving near‑term commercial potential and providing residential units; several commissioners said they favored flexibility that would allow the site to convert to additional commercial space if demand emerges. One commissioner suggested childcare or neighborhood‑serving commercial uses as likely fits for the location.
The commission approved a motion to recommend approval of the development agreement — to permit an initial 3,000 square feet of commercial on the main floor and to treat the building height as four stories in lieu of a strict 40‑foot cap — and will forward the recommendation to City Council for final action.
