Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Government Operations— Taxonomy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee postpones vaping product registry bill after lengthy testimony from industry representatives
Summary
After extended testimony from vape industry representatives, the House Government Operations Committee postponed action on House Bill 968, which would create a state registry for vapor products and included a newly adopted universal carding amendment.
House Bill 968, presented by Representative Hogg, drew extended public testimony and was rolled for further consideration after committee members heard from vape industry representatives and asked questions about enforcement, product authorization, and public-health impacts.
Representative Hogg said the bill responds to concerns that unregulated vape products are reaching juveniles and would "create a registry and ensure that products sold in the stores are only those products on the path to be acceptable to the US FDA." He said amendment draft code 003732 would add a universal carding requirement akin to carding for alcohol and tobacco.
The committee adopted Amendment 003732 by voice vote; the chair recorded "Ayes have it. Amendment is on the bill." (no roll-call tally was recorded in the transcript.)
Testimony from industry representatives followed after the committee briefly went out of session. Danny Gillis, president of the Tennessee Smoke Free Association, told the committee, "Make no mistake, this is a big tobacco crafted bill. It is an attack on the state of Tennessee's vaping industry, our stores, and more importantly, on the rights of every adult consumer to access harm reduction products." Gillis said the bill would immediately pull the vast majority of nicotine vaping products from the market and asserted economic impacts: "If this bill passes, around 700,000 adult nicotine consumers in Tennessee would be left without access to these safer products. Approximately 700 stores will be end up closing, including 3 of my own. Approximately 2,200 jobs will be lost." He also said the bill would "require the state to create a registry to monitor and enforce products we can sell" and contended the FDA is already performing analogous oversight.
Chris Lutz, vice president of Tennessee Smoke Free, provided sales and enforcement statistics from other states that have enacted registry-like measures and said those states saw declines in tax revenue and increases in smuggling; he cited Massachusetts, New York and California as examples.
Members asked detailed questions about which products are FDA-authorized and the pipeline of applications. Witnesses disputed commonly cited product counts: Gillis said retailers see many products in the market and that only a small number (he identified 34) currently have FDA marketing orders; other witnesses said the FDA does not publish a complete list of applications in review. Committee members raised concerns about enforcement, youth access in schools, advertising and store practices, and whether licensing, licensure of retailers, or restricting flavored or closed systems should be used instead of a registry.
After extended discussion and testimony, Representative Hogg said he would "roll the bill" for one week so proponents could appear at the next hearing; the committee agreed to take the item up again at reconvening. No final committee vote on passage was recorded; the committee adopted an amendment by voice vote and postponed further action.
Key details recorded in the hearing: Amendment 003732 (universal carding) was adopted by voice vote; committee recorded no roll-call tally for that amendment in the transcript. Public testimony included specific economic and enforcement claims from Tennessee Smoke Free Association representing retail interests. The sponsor indicated the bill would prohibit sale of any vapor product not listed on the proposed directory and would require retail ID checks under the amendment.
