Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Tax Expenditures topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Lawmakers probe tax expenditure report; administration defends reliance on Authority reporting and warns of tradeoffs
Summary
Committee members pressed the tax department on tax-expenditure transparency, potential elimination of duplicate IDA reporting requirements, sales‑tax exemptions such as for gold bullion, and the effectiveness of economic development credits including Excelsior and film credits.
Legislators used the hearing to press the administration on tax expenditures, reporting and targeted credits. Senator Gounardis and others asked whether the Department of Taxation and Finance would continue publishing estimates currently derived from Industrial Development Authority (IDA) reports if the executive budget eliminates a separate IDA reporting obligation.
Acting Commissioner Ball said the tax department accesses sales‑tax exemption data through the Authority Budget Office (ABO) and the online PERA system and that removing a duplicative IDA reporting requirement would ease IDAs' burden without diminishing oversight. Ball added the department would still publish estimates based on ABO reporting and would rely on existing channels.
Lawmakers also questioned the administration about large, specific exemptions highlighted in the tax expenditure report, including more than $600,000,000 in sales tax foregone on certain bullion transactions. Ball outlined why the exemption exists — citing industry practices where ownership transfers on paper rather than physical movement — and warned that eliminating the exemption could prompt firms to relocate bullion and reduce New York's role in financial services.
Committee members and outside witnesses debated the returns on economic development credits. The tax department and several witnesses discussed the independent tax expenditure study and differing evaluations of programs such as the Excelsior jobs program and the film tax credit. Advocates and analysts pressed for clearer metrics and tighter evaluation. Acting Commissioner Ball said the department produces expenditure estimates but that program goals and broader policy judgments often lie with economic development agencies.
Witnesses and members also raised the idea of reclaiming revenue from narrow exemptions benefiting high‑wealth taxpayers (examples cited included yachts, private jets, and sales‑tax exclusions) and suggested restoring limits on some deductions and rebates. Outside advocates urged higher marginal rates on very high incomes and less rebate of certain Wall Street taxes as potential revenue sources.
