Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Comments Student Safety Residency topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Student urges procedures to let closeted LGBTQ students join GSA without parental consent; another commenter raises residency grievance against board member
Summary
Two public commentators at the Dec. 10 School Board of Manatee County meeting urged different actions: an 11th-grade student asked the district to adopt procedures so closeted LGBTQ students can join a Gay'Straight Alliance without mandatory parental notice in dangerous cases; a second speaker said a newly seated board member may not meet residency rules and signaled he would seek state review.
Two public commentators used the School Board of Manatee County's Dec. 10 public comment period to raise separate policy concerns: one urged district rules to protect closeted LGBTQ students seeking support groups, and another said a newly seated board member did not meet residency requirements and may seek review from state election authorities.
"Because of familial rejection, internalized homophobia, and harassment, LGBT students face significantly higher rates of suicide," said Jack Lawrence, who identified himself as an 11th-grade student at Lakewood Ranch High School. Lawrence described founding a Gay'Straight Alliance at his school and said a local Parental Rights and Education Act implementation requires parental consent for students to join such clubs. He requested the board adopt procedures to withhold parental notification when a "reasonably prudent person would believe the disclosure would result in abuse, abandonment, or neglect," citing language he attributed to the law and advocacy groups. "By establishing such procedures, the closeted LGBT students who are the most at risk of familial rejection and suicide would be able to have a support network possibly saving lives," Lawrence said.
Board members did not take immediate action on Lawrence's request during the meeting; public-comment items prompted no formal agenda item at that session. The transcript records no immediate staff commitment to draft or return a policy, though board members acknowledged the comment and thanked the student.
Another commenter, Jack May, used his public comment time to say he was presenting a "redress of grievance" alleging that school board member Charles Kennedy failed to meet legal residency requirements at the time he took his oath Nov. 19. May referenced "Article 1, Section 5" concerning the right to assemble and quoted guidance on residency evidence such as driver's license, tax receipts, utility bills and homestead declarations. Board staff acknowledged receipt of May's written report but treated his remarks as public comment; legal staff said people at public comment have the same three-minute allowance as other speakers. May said he plans to seek resolution through the state Division of Elections if the board does not place the issue on its agenda.
Board chair and legal staff told the meeting that public comment procedures allow submission of documents and that any formal grievance that requires legal review would be handled according to applicable policies. "We've accepted your written report," meeting officials told May, while also noting the board cannot extend public comment time beyond the stated limit. The board did not take formal action on either public comment item during the meeting.
(Transcript excerpts used in provenance.)
