Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Appointments Diversity topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
San Antonio committee outlines expanded outreach for planning commission appointments amid south-side representation concerns
Summary
City staff reported expanded outreach and application changes for open Planning Commission seats; councilmembers from southern districts said outreach missed many residents and asked for additional engagement and transparency about applicant geography.
San Antonio city staff told the Planning and Development Committee that it broadened outreach and revised the application for open seats on the Planning Commission to encourage geographic diversity, but several councilmembers said applicants are overwhelmingly coming from the north of the city and asked for more targeted outreach to south-side neighborhoods.
The committee was reminded that the citizen appointment request (CCR) originated with Councilmember Villagrán and was presented June 18, 2024, then assigned to the Government Committee on Aug. 16 and to the Planning and Development Committee after questions about geographic diversity. Staff said they added five new questions to the application asking applicants about areas of the city where they have lived, including whether they have lived in District 1, 3 or 9, and that the application period ran Dec. 3–31, 2024.
Why it matters: The councilmembers from southern districts said the apparent lack of applicants from the south could limit the Planning Commission’s understanding of development issues in those neighborhoods, and they urged additional outreach and procedural transparency so appointments reflect citywide representation.
Committee staff reported outreach steps that included postings on the city’s “SA Speak Up” site, social media (Facebook, Instagram, LinkedIn), email notifications, text alerts, PDFs/ flyers distributed to registered neighborhood associations, community organizations, senior centers, libraries and district offices. Staff said they reviewed 28 applications, asked some applicants to resubmit updated applications, and formed a screening subcommittee (members named in the meeting as Cabello Jávera and Courrey) to reduce the list to 12 applicants. Interviews for the shortlisted candidates are scheduled for Feb. 19; names would be presented to the City Council the first week of March, staff said.
Councilmember Villagrán and Councilmember Castillo each said they had not seen the outreach materials and noted the December posting window overlapped major holidays, which they said likely reduced participation. Villagrán asked staff to provide the outreach materials and the list of 28 applicants, and requested counts showing how many applicants live in the south compared with the north. Castillo said she had been working to recruit applicants from District 5 but had not seen applicants from that district in the materials she received.
Committee members discussed whether to form a broader subcommittee that would include members of both Planning & Development and Government Committee to oversee recruitment and ensure quorum and open-meeting rules are observed. No formal motion to change the committee structure or re-open the application period was recorded in the committee minutes excerpted here.
The committee chair closed the discussion and moved on to the next agenda item.
