Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Electronic Voting topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee debates push-button electronic voting tied to House Bill 158
Summary
Committee members reviewed proposed rule changes that would implement a push-button electronic voting system if House Bill 158 is enacted and installed; members discussed transparency, potential 'ghost voting,' staff time, and public access to real-time vote records.
The Rules & Procedure Committee reviewed draft rule changes that would take effect if House Bill 158—legislation to create a push-button electronic voting system for both chambers—is enacted and an electronic voting system is installed before the 2026 session.
Director (Legislative Service Office) explained the provisions are contingent on HB 158 and described current online vote-display functionality: when a roll call occurs, a web page lists the motion and all senators; as the chief clerk enters each vote, a senator’s name changes color and a letter appears (for example, a green 'y' for aye). The director said the current system permits real-time viewing but does not create a permanent record until the clerk closes the vote and the final tally appears in the official digest.
Under the proposed rules tied to HB 158, the number of recorded votes would increase to include nearly all motions (with exceptions listed in proposed Rule 12-13D, such as motions to adjourn, recess and withdraw). The draft generally provides one minute for each vote through the electronic system and allows abbreviated timing for some reconsideration or consent votes.
Senator Dan Larson (co-sponsor of HB 158) advocated for adopting push-button voting, saying a shorter per-vote time and a button-based vote could streamline certain floor actions. Larson told the committee he had discussed technical timing options with the chief clerk and supports experimenting with reduced time for routine votes.
Other senators warned of tradeoffs. One member said a push-button system could encourage legislators to 'run to the floor, hit a button and walk right back out the door,' risking a loss of deliberation and encouraging 'ghost voting' practices observed in other states. Several members also pointed to the existing transparency from livestreamed roll calls and YouTube recordings, noting they had personally reviewed video to confirm how they voted.
Chief Clerk Ellen described the mechanics and timing differences in current practice and the House system: reading the roll call typically takes under a minute in the Senate; House roll calls can run between 1.5 and 2+ minutes depending on vote variation. Committee members asked staff to weigh timing, public accessibility, potential for misuse, and protective measures to ensure members are present and listening when votes occur.
No rule changes were adopted; committee members signaled continued interest in the policy but requested further work on safeguards, timing and public access before any vote to adopt the proposed rules.
