Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the School Construction And Grade Configuration topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
School committee debates 7'12 vs. 9'12 configuration as MSBA design work proceeds
Summary
Members discussed whether the new campus should house grades 7'12 or remain 9'12, citing tradeoffs including specialized spaces, middle-school identity, sixth-grade placement and MSBA timelines. The superintendent proposed placing a configuration vote on Feb. 3.
Members of the Salem School Committee spent much of the Jan. 21 meeting discussing grade configuration for the planned new high-school campus and how the choice would affect middle school programming, shared facilities and project timelines with the Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA).
Member Amber Cornell, who serves on the building committee, opened the discussion by emphasizing that design firms support the district's educational plan but do not determine pedagogy. Cornell said designers have focused on the high school because that portion of the project is already funded and thus most concrete in the design work.
Speaking to concerns from middle-school teachers and parents, Cornell said community input included worries about losing a separate middle-school identity and supervision when students share space with older students. "Middle school students deserve an educational experience that is unique to them," Cornell said.
Member Mary Manning delivered an extended critique of putting the middle school on the high-school campus, arguing the existing Collins Middle School building already contains program-specific spaces'audience-sized auditorium, multiple music and art rooms, culinary and technology-education areas'that could be difficult to replicate or equitably share in a 7'12 design. "The building itself... is fitted for the middle school, architecturally, almost perfectly," Manning said, and she warned that shared scheduling and rightsizing could reduce middle-school access to specialized rooms.
Supporters of a 7'12 configuration argued it could increase access to specialized labs, athletics and extracurricular options, create mentoring opportunities and make more efficient use of district resources. Opponents raised questions about traffic at the high-school site, the supervision of shared spaces, scheduling tradeoffs and how to serve sixth graders if the district shifts grade spans.
Superintendent Dr. Streich said the district had conducted multiple community meetings (including an all-Spanish session at El Espa—o), staff sessions and outreach to teachers and students. He proposed placing a vote on grade configuration on the Feb. 3 school committee agenda so designers can proceed with MSBA-required timelines. "My suggestion is that this is a draft, and, I'll ask school committee for a final vote at the February 3rd meeting," Streich said.
Committee members requested additional materials to inform their decisions, including a list of other 7'12 districts in the region, recent MSBA projects and accountability/comparison data for 7'12 schools. Several members asked for school visits to districts that had recently built 7'12 or 9'12 facilities. No final vote was held Jan. 21; the committee set a planned process for follow-up prior to the Feb. 3 agenda deadline.
