Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Signage Fence Coa topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board approves 4‑foot fence and existing sign at 521 SE Second Street; staff had recommended sign not appropriate
Summary
The board approved an after‑the‑fact 4‑foot black aluminum fence and a 7‑by‑3.16‑foot sign at 521 Southeast Second Street despite a staff recommendation that the sign replacement was not consistent with historic signage guidelines; the fence was recommended and approved.
The City of Ocala preservation board approved an after‑the‑fact Certificate of Appropriateness for a 4‑foot high black aluminum fence and for a 7‑by‑3.16‑foot sign at 521 Southeast Second Street (case file 347COA24‑7). Planning staff presented photos and a block‑level comparison, saying the fence met the Certificate of Appropriateness criteria (Section 94‑86) but that the new sign did not align with historic signage patterns on that block and therefore was "not appropriate" under COA criteria.
Applicant Crystal Snook, who identified herself and her address at the hearing, told the board the sign had been used at her previous location for five years and is similar to a sign on the Presbyterian church across the street. She said the building had undergone recent renovations and she planned landscaping and lighting beneath the sign to soften its appearance.
Board members discussed the differences between regulatory code (the sign met zoning height and square‑footage limits) and the historic guidelines the board applies. Some members said the new sign did not substantially differ from typical signage nearby, and that landscaping or lowering the sign could mitigate visual impact; others pointed to staff concerns about precedent if multiple businesses began replacing older signs with a different style. One board member suggested the applicant could consider black pole sleeves or lowered placement to reduce visual prominence.
A motion to approve both the fence and the sign was made, seconded and carried by voice vote. After the vote the chair reiterated COA process details: COAs are valid for six months from approval, construction must start within that window and projects should finish within 12 months unless staff grants an extension.
