Nickel Plate Review Committee tables Mayfield Townhomes after committee seeks stronger 116th Street elevation

The Nickel Plate Review Committee of Fishers City continued action on Mayfield Townhomes (NPRC 25-2) on Oct. 29 after staff and the petitioner presented three townhome elevation types and committee members asked for stronger streetscape treatments along East 116th Street.

Ross Hillary, Fishers City staff, told the committee the application requests approval of three townhome elevations submitted by Old Town Design Group for the Mayfield (also referenced in the packet as Mapledel/Mabeledale) Subdivision. The site is zoned BC (Village Center) and is located generally south of East 116th Street near the intersection of Taubman/Hollott Drive; the full submittal includes a mix of single-family lots and townhomes with a single vehicular access point off Collin Drive. Hillary said staff recommended approval with one condition: that all tax comments be addressed.

Hillary described the three elevation families: the East 116th Street (street-facing) elevations, alley-loaded elevations and front-load elevations. Materials shown include masonry and hardy plank with board-and-batten detailing; some building sides will have brick…