Commission asks for more documentation on proposed siding changes for house and carriage house

Applicants presented a conceptual application to replace existing exterior siding on the main house and to install new siding on a carriage house. HPO staff and commissioners asked for additional documentation: a site visit, a measured drawing showing the existing siding and trim, and clearer details about material and installation method for the carriage house’s roof form and paneling.

Staff noted that composite or artificial siding may be an acceptable permanent solution in some circumstances but that installing siding over existing historic fabric generally does not comply with the Durham Village design guidance. The commission advised the applicants to schedule an on‑site evaluation with Historic Preservation Office staff and to prepare a full application with specific product cut sheets and section drawings for review at a future meeting.

No vote was taken; the item was treated as a conceptual review and staff will follow up with the applicants to arrange inspection and to provide guideline materials and trim standards. The commission said that where existing historic trim deviates from the design standard, the existing condition will guide staff recommendations.