Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Works topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council rejects Munhall snow‑removal agreement; approves purchase of additional vehicles
Summary
Councilwoman Barbara Warwick proposed an intermunicipal 'agility' agreement with the borough of Munhall to provide snow removal assistance during heavy events; council voted the agreement down but approved vehicle purchases to bolster the city fleet.
PITTSBURGH — The standing committee considered an intermunicipal cooperation resolution (Bill 20‑62) that would have allowed Munhall to provide snow‑and‑ice removal on specified Pittsburgh streets "as resources allow," and a separate bill (Bill 23‑32) to increase Equipment Leasing Authority authorization to purchase vehicles and equipment for Public Works.
Councilwoman Barbara Warwick, who represents a district abutting Munhall, framed the Munhall agreement as a targeted, resource‑sharing pilot for isolated neighborhoods that are far from the city’s Division 3 maintenance yards. "If we had nine or 10 trucks in Greenfield, we would have the snow up in two hours as well," Warwick said, urging practical solutions for parts of the city that are geographically distant from yards.
Director of Public Works Chris Hornstein told the committee the draft agreement would permit mutual assistance "as resources allow," including allowing Munhall to store salt in Munhall’s salt dome for city use, and the borough to provide snow removal on city streets adjacent to Munhall if Munhall has capacity. Hornstein also said the city would provide certain services back as resources allow.
Labor leaders and several councilmembers raised immediate concerns about union and collective‑bargaining implications. "Who's not for it is the heads of our unions, the Teamsters… They are adamantly against this," said Councilman Charland, reporting conversations he said he had with Teamsters representatives. Council members argued a cross‑municipal crew arrangement could run afoul of existing bargaining agreements or undermine overtime opportunities for city crews.
On roll call, the Munhall agreement (Bill 20‑62) failed: the clerk recorded 2 ayes and 7 noes. Separately, council voted to increase the Equipment Leasing Authority authorization to purchase vehicles (Bill 23‑32). That measure passed on roll call with a recorded tally of 7 ayes and 2 noes; sponsors said the purchase is intended to begin to address fleet shortages that limited winter responsiveness.
Why it matters: Public Works officials and councilmembers described persistent fleet shortfalls; residents in remote neighborhoods had complained about slow plowing response times after heavy snow. The Munhall agreement sought a short‑term, capacity‑sharing option; unions and several councilmembers said equipment purchases and internal capacity‑building remain the preferred route.
What’s next: Councilmembers requested further, formal conversations with the city’s bargaining units and additional details from the law department on legal risk; vehicle procurement timelines remain subject to vendor lead times and budget completion.
