Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Education Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Haverhill councilors criticize state‑mandated unweighted lottery for Whittier Tech admissions
Summary
Councilors at the Oct. 15 meeting said the new state law replacing weighted admissions could exclude highly motivated, high‑performing Haverhill students. Members urged coordination among Haverhill High, Whittier Tech and Northern Essex Community College and asked Whittier Tech representatives to return with details of the policy.
Councilors used a lengthy Oct. 15 discussion to press concerns about a state‑mandated shift to an unweighted lottery for admissions to Whittier Tech.
Councilor Mitchison summarized the policy as "the lottery in a nutshell is when more students apply to Woodia Vo Tech then we have available seats," and said the change could let disadvantaged students in who might not otherwise gain admission while also excluding academically strong applicants. Several councilors said Haverhill will retain roughly 70% of available seats based on a 10‑year average but disagreed slightly about the exact percent cited in public discussion (council estimates ranged near 68–72 percent).
Councilor Toohey said the system risks denying seats to "highly motivated and qualified students" and pressed questions about whether funding per Haverhill student would remain unchanged; councilors reported the per‑student funding figure discussed by representatives was about $10,000. Several speakers urged that the new lottery heighten the need for interagency coordination: Haverhill High School, Whittier Tech and Northern Essex Community College will need to plan for any changes in enrollment and facility use if Whittier expands seat capacity.
Councilors also discussed whether behavioral or attendance standards could be used to weight the lottery. Mitchison and others said the school committee chose a pure (unweighted) lottery; councilors noted the original state guidance allowed weighting but that the Whittier committee had not adopted such stipulations. Questions about how unfilled slots from other sending communities would be redistributed also remained unanswered at the meeting.
Mayor Melinda E. Barrett and councilors noted the Massachusetts School Building Authority (MSBA) prescribes membership rules for building committees; while students may attend public meetings, the MSBA does not typically provide voting slots for students on building committees.
Whittier Tech representatives are expected to appear at a future council meeting to present the policy in greater detail and answer outstanding questions.
