Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Field Trips topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board approves high‑school music trip after heated debate over field‑trip funding
Summary
The Carmel Central School District Board approved a high‑school music field trip that charges $100 per student after trustees debated whether district field‑trip funds should be used to reduce parent costs. An amendment to transfer $2,500 from the general fund to subsidize the trip failed in a roll‑call vote.
The Carmel Central School District Board of Education on Oct. 7 approved a high‑school music department field trip that will charge students $100 each, after an extended debate over whether district funds should be used to reduce parent costs.
The measure, presented at the Oct. 7 meeting at Carmel High School Library, passed on a roll call after trustees considered and rejected an amendment that would have transferred $2,500 from the general fund to lower the per‑student cost.
Trustee Wise said the board has repeatedly stated support for lowering family costs and urged the district to ensure field‑trip budgets are used as intended. “I would love to see all the money that it allocated for field trips used for field trips so that there is no money to go back in the general fund,” Trustee Wise said during debate.
Administrators told the board the field‑trip form in the agenda packet was confusing: one line listed $6,668 as subsidized and $10,000 as student payments, for a combined total the administration described during the meeting as roughly $16,000. Carmel High School Principal Brian Piazza clarified that the $6,668 figure reflects funds allocated from the CHS field‑trip budget, not PTO support or outside fundraising.
Trustees pressed administration about whether the district could reallocate funds to reduce costs. Trustee Torpey and others said they would prefer districtwide planning rather than pulling money ad hoc during a meeting. An amendment to transfer $2,500 failed in a roll‑call vote (two trustees supported the amendment and the majority opposed), and the original field‑trip resolution was adopted.
The board also asked administration to provide a comprehensive field‑trip budget at the Oct. 21 meeting showing allocations by school and department and listing recurring trips. The administration agreed to request principals outline planned trips as part of next year’s budget process.
Supporters of the trip and other trustees emphasized that, in practice, individual teachers and departments have historically arranged financial assistance so students are not excluded. “No student was ever excluded for a trip for financial means,” said a member of the public and parent speaking in support of the music program.
