The Carmel Central School District Board of Education on Oct. 21 approved the district's proposed set of field trips — including the eighth-grade Washington, D.C. trip — and heard a five-point plan to standardize field-trip policy, forms and funding.
The review, led by assistant superintendent Dr. Gorman, recommended immediate operational changes, including not charging students for use of district buses for one-way trips up to 75 miles except for driver pay and mileage, adopting a new online workflow for trip requests, earlier projection of next years major trips for board review, a minimum expectation of at least one quality, curriculum-linked field trip per grade, and a year-end evaluation of each trip.
Why it matters: Trustees framed the changes as both efficiency and equity measures. Several said they were troubled that, until now, students were sometimes charged for using district buses as if they were external customers. Trustee Wise pressed for steps to ensure students who cannot afford high-cost trips do not miss capstone experiences. The Washington, D.C. trip was discussed at length: the per-student price cited in discussion was $870 and a $400 deposit was in effect for this year's registration.
Dr. Gorman said the district will "immediately recommend that anything 1 way up to 75 miles, we use district buses and we don't charge our kids for buses except for the drivers and mileage." The board asked administration to treat the change as effective for trips moving forward and to return at the next meeting with a line-item cost breakdown for the Washington, D.C. itinerary.
Access and affordability: Trustees and the superintendent agreed on three measures to reduce barriers: (1) centralized, confidential assistance and payment-plan options to ensure families who cannot afford deposits or full payments can still participate; (2) earlier budgeting so the board can consider general-fund help during the annual budget process; and (3) clearer communication with families (including check-box options on sign-up materials) so parents do not have to request help in person.
Board action: The board voted to approve the field-trip requests as recommended by the superintendent after an executive-session legal consultation. The motion carried; the board asked administration to detail costs and to publish messaging that includes payment plans and confidential assistance options before final payments are due.
What remains unresolved: Trustees asked the district to evaluate whether any trips that require coach buses or enter New York City should require explicit board approval. They also requested that the Frontline Central field-trip module or a new integrated form be piloted to replace the current standalone form.
The boards vote on field trips and the commitment to ensure any student who cannot afford a trip will have access were recorded during the meeting; the administration will present the requested cost breakdowns and a plan for confidential financial assistance at the next board meeting.