Commission recommends variance to allow billiards/arcade at 646 West Market Street

New York City Planning Commission · November 11, 2025

Get AI-powered insights, summaries, and transcripts

Sign Up Free
AI-Generated Content: All content on this page was generated by AI to highlight key points from the meeting. For complete details and context, we recommend watching the full video. so we can fix them.

Summary

An applicant seeking a variance to permit a commercial recreation facility (billiards/arcade) at 646 West Market Street received the commission's recommendation after proponents — including a veterans group member — spoke in favor.

The Planning Commission recommended approval of a variance to allow a commercial recreation facility (billiards/arcade) at 646 West Market Street in the UN‑1 urban mixed residential‑commercial district.

Applicant James DeShields (stating he is operating on behalf of Lockwood Property Holdings LLC) described the intended use as a pool hall/arcade and confirmed that the space formerly served commercial purposes. Planning staff noted the item was advertised as a special exception but advised that it should be considered a variance; the applicant will be rescheduled for the zoning hearing board in December for final hearing because of advertising requirements.

Rich Monroe, a combat‑disabled veteran and member of local American Legion and VFW posts, urged the commission to approve the variance, saying a pool hall would provide social space for veterans who lack gathering places. Commissioners moved and seconded to recommend approval of the variance (cited as section 13.04.01‑4.0.006 in the transcript), and the motion was accepted by roll call. The recommendation will be forwarded to the zoning hearing board and city staff for the required subsequent hearings and notices.

No final administrative or council action was taken at the meeting; the applicant will proceed to the required zoning board hearing and any subsequent approvals.