Fullerton residents accuse city of heavy‑handed enforcement after Les Amis patio was torn down
Loading...
Summary
Multiple residents and business owners told the Fullerton City Council the city removed an outdoor patio at Les Amis after raising outdoor dining fees; the city said the restaurant had a long history of nonpayment and that fee increases were council‑approved — council directed staff to return with more detail Dec. 2.
Fullerton — Dozens of residents packed City Hall on Nov. 4 to criticize the city’s enforcement of outdoor dining fees and to urge the council to restore a popular dining patio at Les Amis in downtown Fullerton.
Business owners and patrons said city crews removed Les Amis’ patio on the morning of Oct. 27 after the restaurant failed to pay newly increased fees. "This wasn't a code conversation or negotiation or a path to resolution. The city literally destroyed her improvements," Christina Larson told the council during public comment, calling the action "hostility" rather than governance.
Owner representatives and speakers at the dais said fees for the small patio rose in recent months from amounts described by some speakers as $1,200 a month to $3,500 a month, a change they said was unsustainable for a small restaurant. Janelle Monicristo (speaking on behalf of Les Amis) said owners were told they had not paid city fees for many years — a claim the business disputes — and she and supporters argued that the city's actions were disproportionate and damaging to downtown vibrancy.
City staff and the city manager told the council the outdoor‑dining fee increases were adopted by council action and that the affected restaurant has a long history of unresolved fees. The city manager said there is a long record and noted prior payments and a 90‑day stay that had been provided; at the meeting the city manager stated an approximate outstanding balance "in the range" of about $2,025,000, a cumulative figure cited during discussion and not broken out in detail at the meeting.
Council response and next steps
Councilmembers accepted residents' requests for more transparency. The mayor asked staff to bring a fuller report to the Dec. 2 meeting that explains the fee changes, notice and enforcement timeline and the specific account balances for the restaurant in question. Councilmember Zara and others pressed for a broader review of outdoor‑dining policy so businesses are treated consistently; Zara said, "When we see a business struggling... we need to review [and] revise our policies to accommodate."
Why it matters
Speakers argued the patio was a cultural and economic asset that drew visitors and supported live music in downtown Fullerton; business owners said demolition cost jobs and destroyed personally created improvements. City staff stressed the city’s obligation to collect fees and enforce code when property encroaches on public right‑of‑way and said the council will revisit the policy at the December meeting.
What the public asked for
Speakers requested a) restoration of Les Amis’ patio or a stay pending a policy review, b) a city accounting of why some patios are charged and others not, and c) a consistent fee schedule aligned with comparable cities. City staff agreed to return with an agenda item and more detailed financial information.
