Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Library Safety topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Library patron says unopened alcohol found in donation bin; city reiterates policy is on consumption, not unopened containers
Summary
A patron reported finding an unopened can of alcohol in a library food‑donation bin and complained about staff response and workplace conduct. City management said library policy prohibits consumption and intoxication, not possession of unopened containers, and that staff filed incident reports and are reviewing policies and food‑bin design.
A Milwaukie resident who raised a concern about an unopened can of alcohol found in a library donation bin told the City Council she felt dismissed after raising the issue, prompting the city manager to explain staff follow‑up and clarify library policy.
At the meeting City Manager Emma recounted the sequence of events after resident Deborah Torres reported the can: a patron told librarians it had been dropped accidentally and the library returned it to that patron; library management and Milwaukie police reviewed incident reports and the city documented follow‑up. “The policy is about consumption and intoxication,” Emma said, describing the city’s interpretation of library rules. She added the city is reviewing library policies and will consider design changes to the donation bin so staff can better monitor items placed in it.
Torres, during public comment, said she was “so astounded at the reaction of the librarian when I presented what I found to be a can of alcohol smack dab in the middle of a food box,” and said she felt the incident and subsequent exchanges were not handled professionally. She identified herself as a longtime resident with professional experience in psychiatry and gerontology and said she was concerned about the bin as a potential hazard for children and vulnerable patrons.
City response and follow‑up: City staff said they have been documenting related patron incidents through the PITS reporting system and that management and the police reviewed the matter. The city manager said Director Husher (Library) followed up with Ms. Torres and acknowledged that some language used in staff interactions “was not appropriate.” Staff reported they will look at modifying the food‑donation bin so it’s easier to monitor and maintain; the city’s legal counsel advised the bin did not meet the legal test for an “attractive nuisance.”
What the council asked for: Council members asked whether the interaction was captured on security cameras and whether the off‑camera remarks were quoted from the patron or were language used by staff. The city manager said staff would review security footage and correspondence and that the matter remains open for follow‑up, including possible additional information from Ms. Torres.
Next steps: Staff indicated they will continue an overall review of library policies, consider bin modifications to improve monitoring, and provide additional follow‑up to the council and public as needed.
