Committee advances bill to protect parents when children engage in reasonable independent activities
Loading...
Summary
The House Children and Youth Committee voted to report House Bill 1873 as amended, a measure sponsored by Chair McNeil that would clarify Pennsylvania law so parents are not charged with neglect or child endangerment when children engage in reasonable independent activities; amendment A02144 passed 26-0 and the committee reported the bill 25-1.
Chair McNeil, sponsor of House Bill 1873, told the House Children and Youth Committee the bill would "allow children to engage in independent activities within reason without parents being charged with neglect or child endangerment." The committee voted to report the bill as amended 25 to 1.
The bill, introduced as Printer's No. 2321 and summarized by committee staff Danielle, would amend Titles 18 (Crime and Offenses), 23 (Domestic Relations) and 42 (Judiciary and Judicial Procedure) of the Pennsylvania Consolidated Statutes. Danielle said the amendment offered by the sponsor, Amendment A02144, replaces an "obvious" standard with language referring to a "foreseeable danger" and adjusts the statutory definition of a dependent child.
Supporters said the change clarifies law and focuses enforcement on actual abuse and endangerment. "It does not weaken child protection laws," McNeil said, adding that the bill seeks to reduce investigations driven by unclear statutory language. She listed 11 states she said have enacted similar protections, and thanked Representatives Kojewski and Zimmerman for cosponsoring.
Representative Zimmerman described personal experience growing up on a farm and said the bill helps "allow kids to be kids" and learn responsibility. Representative Pugh voiced support for the bill's intent but said she would vote no because she remains concerned about children in less-responsible homes. Chair Klunk noted that the Pennsylvania Council on Children, Youth, and Family Services (PCYA) had raised concerns and said she hoped floor amendments could address agency issues.
The committee first approved Amendment A02144 by roll call (26 ayes, 0 nays). On the question of reporting the bill as amended, the committee voted 25 ayes and 1 nay and the bill was reported as amended. No formal opposition was recorded in committee testimony. The bill will move forward with the amendment and any subsequent floor amendments the sponsors pursue.
