Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Judicial Recommendations Questions topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Governors approve Judicial Recommendations Committee interview questions with one dissent
Summary
A panel of governors voted to approve a set of Judicial Recommendations Committee interview questions proposed by the committee; the item was discussed as confidential and the motion passed with one negative vote.
A panel of governors voted to approve the Judicial Recommendations Committee’s interview questions after counselors debated whether the committee should be limited to a fixed set of questions. The motion passed in a roll-call vote with one dissenting vote.
An unidentified member moved to "approve the judicial recommendations committee questions" as proposed by the committee, and the motion was seconded before a roll-call vote. The JRC liaison described the committee’s role as determining whether a candidate is well qualified and forwarding that assessment to the governor, and said the committee (about 22 members) recommended a specific list of questions tied to the evaluation elements and that only those questions be asked, though follow-up questions would be permitted based on candidate responses. The liaison said that recommendation was not unanimous.
Comments during the public portion of the agenda (not part of the executive-session discussion of legal risks) focused on the scope of the questions and whether limiting the committee to a fixed list would impede its ability to probe candidates. The chair noted materials for the item are confidential and had been discussed in executive session; members restricted their on-the-record discussion to non-legal aspects.
During roll call, recorded votes were: Governor Ahern — yes; Governor Wynne — yes; Governor Arneson — yes; Governor Couch — aye; Governor Vang — yes; Governor Larry — yes; Governor Dresden — yes; Governor Rathbone — yes; Governor Faye — no, saying, "To reflect the dissension on the council, I'm going to vote no;" Governor Price — yes; Governor Bloom — aye; Governor Petrosic — yes. The presiding officer announced the motion passed with one negative vote.
No statutes, ordinances, or other legal authorities were cited on the record during the open discussion. The decision implements the committee’s recommended question set for JRC interviews; no amendments or follow-up assignments were recorded on the public record.
The meeting moved on after the announcement of the vote; the record shows the committee’s recommendation (as described by the liaison) and the roll-call result as the substantive on-the-record outcome of this agenda item.
