Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the School Climate Survey topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
School committee approves districtwide climate survey as opt-out after debate on demographics and sample size
Summary
The Burlington School Committee approved administration of a school climate survey for grades 4–12 (proposed Dec. 15–19) as an opt-out, after discussion about demographic questions, data protections and the risk that opt-in would reduce sample size needed for reliable subgroup analysis.
The Burlington School Committee voted to approve administration of a districtwide school climate survey for students in grades 4 through 12, to be administered Dec. 15–19, and to make participation opt-out rather than opt-in.
District staff described the instrument as drawn from the Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS) center and administered through ThoughtExchange. Presenters said the survey covers school connectedness, peer and adult social support, cultural acceptance, civic learning, physical environment and safety. District staff emphasized data protections: one-time unique survey links, de-identification of responses, no IP tracking, and automatic suppression of any group with fewer than five responses to reduce re-identification risk.
Several committee members supported opt-out administration because they said an opt-in approach was unlikely to produce the sample sizes needed for reliable subgroup analysis. One member argued that an opt-in survey “would be a waste of all your effort” if response rates were too low to meet statistical thresholds; another said the data are vital to safety and program planning and that recent experience showed opt-in would likely fail to reach the needed numbers.
Opponents and some parents raised concerns about specific demographic items, including a question about gender assigned at birth. A committee member said that particular question could make some families uncomfortable given recent community debate; district staff responded that every demographic item includes an “I prefer not to answer” option and that families will see all questions in advance and may opt their children out via the ParentSquare notification process.
District staff confirmed they will follow the district’s survey-notification policy, which requires at least 15 days’ notice and multiple communications to families. The committee’s approval included the opt-out administration model and instructions to publish the survey questions and opt-out procedures in advance.
The next steps include finalizing administration dates, publishing the full question set to families, and running the survey through ThoughtExchange with the stated privacy protections. The committee did not change the content of the presented instruments beyond the administration method.
