Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Comments Education Equity topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Public commenter urges play‑based early learning and criticizes 'social promotion' at Binghamton board meeting
Summary
Dr. Missy Kirby, an educator and local volunteer, told the board that the district's longstanding practice of promoting students who are not meeting grade‑level skills is "undignified," urged a return to play‑based early childhood learning, and recommended district office staff spend time working in schools to build relationships.
During the public comment portion of the meeting, Dr. Missy Kirby — introduced herself as having a PhD in education policy and decades of classroom experience — urged the district to prioritize play‑based early childhood education, stronger family engagement and concrete steps to address persistent literacy and numeracy gaps.
Kirby told the board she has raised concerns repeatedly since 2023 and praised recent attention to homelessness and dignity prompted by newly elected board members. She criticized the district's practice of social promotion and said it contributes to low literacy and inequitable outcomes for students of color: "Your racist practice of social promotion is undignified," she said. Kirby recommended concrete actions including reintroducing play in pre‑K and kindergarten, increasing district staff presence in schools (suggested two days per month for district office employees), and stronger family‑facing supports.
Board members thanked Kirby for her comments; no formal administrative response was made during the public comment slot other than to accept her remarks into the record and direct follow‑up through appropriate school channels. Kirby's testimony was part of a larger public comment segment that addressed equity, school culture and the connection between family engagement and student outcomes.
