Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Open Meetings topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Neptune Beach council debates virtual public comment; mayor calls proposal 'a terrible idea'
Summary
Councilors debated whether to permit remote public comment during regular meetings. Proponents cited access and a successful COVID‑era pilot; opponents, including the mayor, warned of legal and moderation risks. No policy change was made; the city attorney can draft a resolution if council directs.
Neptune Beach — The city council held a lengthy debate on allowing members of the public to provide comment remotely during regular meetings, a policy often called 'hybrid' public comment.
Councilor Messenger and other supporters said virtual access increases participation for residents who cannot attend in person and recommended piloting the practice for a limited period. “We did it during COVID... it was very successful,” Councilor Messenger said, urging a pilot and moderation plan.
Mayor Bylinski strongly opposed opening public comment to remote callers, saying it would be hard to control nonresident callers and First Amendment auditors who the mayor said sometimes seek to provoke officials. “I think it's a terrible idea,” the mayor said. The city attorney and the chief of police explained legal constraints and enforcement limits for disruptive callers, noting moderation is possible but that public‑meeting protections limit excluding speech unless it becomes disruptive or criminal.
Council made no change to the city's current procedure that prioritizes in‑person public comment; the city attorney offered to draft a resolution if council wants one for a future vote. Several councilors asked staff to study options such as written submissions, resident‑only portals (noting legal limits) or a limited pilot tied to town‑hall sessions.
