Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
West Fargo approves Hope Lutheran rezoning but withholds immediate 6th Street access
Summary
After heated debate about pedestrian safety and traffic modeling, the commission approved rezoning and final plat for the Hope Lutheran addition with a development agreement condition that bars immediate access onto 6th Street West; the developer may request access later if the area east is platted.
The West Fargo City Commission on Oct. 6 voted to approve the second reading of the rezoning ordinance and the final plat for the proposed Hope Lutheran addition, but with a condition that denies immediate access to 6th Street West and allows the developer to request that access later if the area to the east is platted or developed.
Aaron Nelson, the city’s director of planning, summarized the request as a rezoning from agricultural to R-1A single-dwelling residential for a single roughly 12-acre lot and reviewed a commission-commissioned traffic study by Bolton and Mink that concluded "the existing roadway system is expected to accommodate traffic from the proposed church with minimal impacts," while recommending two mitigation measures: a turn lane on 9th Street and additional pedestrian-crossing signage at the 9th Street access points.
Opponents told the commission they feared safety problems on nearby 6th Street, which is a quiet, local road adjacent to Lacey Elementary School. Resident Mike Meschewski said the study underestimated pedestrian risks and special events, arguing, "This is not just an oversight, this is a recipe for risk," and urged the commission to remove the 6th Street access and restrict the development to 9th Street. Resident Joshua Crank pressed the scale of the project — including a parking lot that would hold more than 400 vehicles — and said even modest increases in peak-period traffic could be “statistically significant” for neighbors.
The church’s project architect, Brian Berg, told the commission the traffic study excluded infrequent events such as most funerals and weddings because they had a minimal aggregate impact; he also noted Hope Lutheran has followed city processes. Traffic engineer Mike Bittner of Bolton and Mink described the traffic-distribution estimate that underlies the 16% figure for 6th Street as based on anonymized GPS "streetlight" data combined with engineering judgment and national pattern studies.
Commissioners debated whether the city has legal authority to bar an access point for a religious institution, noting federal law affords certain protections for religious uses. Legal counsel and planning staff advised the commission that the city could seek the "least restrictive means" to address safety concerns and include conditions in the development agreement that trigger reconsideration of access if the neighboring tract is platted in the future.
Commissioner Anderson moved to approve the rezoning and plat with the development-agreement condition that 6th Street access be withheld until the area east is platted or otherwise requires additional infrastructure; Commissioner Zundell seconded. On roll call, Anderson and Zundell voted yes, Olsen voted aye and Jorgensen voted no; the motion passed.
The development agreement and subsequent site and building permits are the next steps; staff said any future request to activate 6th Street access would come back to the city for review against the agreed triggers and safety standards.
