Board members raise concerns about DPI's report‑card changes, urge monitoring
Loading...
Summary
Board members said changes to the Wisconsin DPI school report‑card methodology — using two years of data, dropping last year's scale adjustment and shifting to growth‑focused metrics — could compress distributions and obscure high‑performing schools' growth; staff will monitor and report back when state data are released.
Board members expressed concern over recent changes the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (DPI) is making to its school report‑card methodology, saying the alterations could change how district performance is displayed across the state.
An unidentified staff speaker summarized the state changes: "They are discontinuing last year's scale adjustment... it's gonna be looking specifically at growth." The speaker said DPI will use two years of data instead of three, stop weighting achievement and aim to make district distributions look more like pre‑pandemic patterns.
Board members warned the changes could make it harder to identify sustained improvements at high‑performing schools and reduce incentives for collaboration. One board member said the policy "makes no sense" if it causes high performers to appear to show less growth while lower‑performing schools show greater change under the new metric.
Why it matters: The state report card influences public perceptions and can affect district benchmarking, community expectations, and the district’s strategic planning. Staff told the board they expect DPI’s updated report in November and an initial look at district‑level data in early October.
Board direction: Members asked staff to continue tracking DPI communications, prepare internal comparisons using the district's own growth measures, and report back once DPI publishes its updated data.
