Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Ois Fdrb Votes topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission reviews officer-involved shooting investigations and firearm discharge reports; holds procedural votes
Summary
The commission received a fourth-quarter Firearm Discharge Review Board and in-custody death update, heard calls from the public for accountability in recent officer-involved shootings (notably the Sean Moore case), and voted to hold a closed-session matter and to keep that discussion confidential.
Sergeant John Crudo of Internal Affairs presented the fourth-quarter Firearm Discharge Review Board (FDRB) and in-custody death summaries at the Feb. 1 meeting. He reported two closed firearm-discharge investigations: one accidental discharge while reloading (no injury, found not in policy) and one accidental discharge during a high-risk warrant (non‑policy finding; bullet lodged in a closet), both with training recommendations. Crudo also reviewed two in-custody death review cases from prior years with mixed findings and summarized the status of open officer‑involved shooting (OIS) investigations: as of late January the department listed 16 open OIS cases, several awaiting DA charging decisions.
Public comment on officer-involved shootings was extensive. Community members and advocacy organizations asked for transparency and disciplinary action in recent cases and raised concerns about racial profiling and the department's response to mental-health crises. Several speakers urged commission action related to the Sean Moore shooting, including training in Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) response and disciplinary review of involved officers. "Sean Moore is a black man with schizophrenia and bipolar disorder...the police body cam footage shows SFPD escalate the situation when Sean clearly needed a crisis intervention team," one commenter said.
On procedure, the commission moved and seconded a motion to hold an item in closed session under the San Francisco Administrative Code; the chair called for the ayes and the motion carried notwithstanding one recorded "No." After closed session the commission voted not to disclose the closed-session discussion and then adjourned.
The commission did not take public final disciplinary votes on OIS cases at this meeting; multiple criminal investigations remain pending the San Francisco District Attorney's charging decisions, as noted by staff.
