Public splits on proposed drive-through ban as council reopens hearing and delays decision

The City Council's Nov. 6 public hearing on proposed zoning changes for drive-throughs drew a mix of pedestrian-safety advocates and business representatives, reflecting sharply split views on whether to prohibit new drive-through facilities.

Student activists from Macalester College urged a full ban on new drive-through construction, arguing "drive throughs are by design prioritizing car access at the expense of other street users" and calling the facilities "incompatible" with pedestrian-oriented neighborhoods. Several nearby residents and disability advocates also testified about pedestrian safety and accessibility concerns.

Business interests including the St. Paul Area Chamber and representatives of local McDonald's operators urged caution. A McDonald's operator said nearly three-quarters of his locations' business is drive-through traffic and asked the council to allow flexibility for future innovations and not to hinder small-business viability, especially in winter months.

Council debate focused on timing and the citywide commercial-corridor zoning study. Councilmember Naker argued the issue should be reconsidered after the corridor study while other members pressed for prompt action to address pedestrian safety. The council voted to reopen the hearing and postpone decision until Sept. 3, 2025, giving more time for public input and alignment with broader corridor planning.

Next steps: The public hearing remains open; councilmembers said staff will return with additional information and planning coordination.