Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Variance topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning commission denies variance for accessory structure at 1003 South Pine
Summary
Commissioners denied a variance request that would have allowed a detached garage 458 sq ft over the allowable limit, citing the long‑standing 10% lot rule and finding the application did not meet variance criteria.
The Newton Planning Commission on Sept. 8 denied a variance request for 1003 South Pine that would have allowed an accessory structure roughly 458 square feet larger than the lot‑based limit.
Justin, planning staff, explained the variance sought to exceed the city’s 10% lot coverage rule for accessory structures. Applicant Dennis Stassen told the commission a fire on June 14 damaged an existing pole‑barn garage; he proposed demolishing the damaged structure and two smaller sheds and building a single 70‑by‑30 garage to consolidate storage and eliminate clutter. Stassen said the new building would be constructed by a licensed contractor and located within rear setbacks.
Commissioners questioned whether the fire‑damage circumstance created a unique condition sufficient for a variance and cautioned against creating a broad precedent for larger accessory buildings. One commissioner noted that the 10% rule has been on the books for many years and that granting the variance could invite similar future requests. A motion to deny the variance, finding the application did not meet the standards for a variance, carried.
Why it matters: The denial preserves the city’s longstanding 10% lot‑coverage standard for accessory structures and signals commissioners’ reluctance to relax that rule absent a clearly exceptional property condition.
What’s next: The applicant may revise the proposal to meet the 10% limit or return with additional justification; staff suggested working with the applicant on alternatives.
