Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Diversity Equity Inclusion topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Residents and trustees clash over proposed revisions to Carmel's welcoming policy
Summary
Dozens of residents urged the Carmel Central School District board not to strip explicit diversity, equity and inclusion language from Policy 0012. Trustees kept the item on the agenda for a first read and asked for further review by the policy committee and legal counsel after vigorous public comment.
Dozens of residents and multiple trustees pressed the Carmel Central School District Board of Education on April 8 after the district's policy committee proposed changes to Policy 0012, entitled “Welcoming, affirming and inclusive environment.”
During public comment, speakers from across the district urged trustees to retain explicit language that recognizes historically marginalized students and commits the district to protecting students from discrimination. Abigail Lyons, who identified herself as a resident and former district student, said she was "appalled and baffled" by the proposed language that would remove direct references to race, discrimination or marginalization and said the change would harm vulnerable students.
Trustee response and procedural outcome
Trustee Wise moved to remove the item from tonight's agenda so trustees could reconsider proposed changes; the board debated whether a first read should proceed. After discussion and a roll‑call on a motion to remove the item from the agenda, the board did not remove the policy review and instead retained it as a first read for further discussion. Trustees requested the policy be returned to the policy committee with additional legal guidance and community input before any final action.
What speakers said
- Abigail Lyons (public comment): Said proposed deletions would remove protections for marginalized students and criticized committee meetings as inaccessible to working parents. - Mike Falloon (public comment): Urged the board to keep language that explicitly states racism, discrimination and marginalization have no place in district schools. - Jurgen Temple and Hans Bernier (public comment): Recounted past district efforts to address hate incidents and urged the board not to reverse course. - Trustee Wise (board): Called the proposed revisions “horrifying” and characterized the deletions as a retreat from commitments the board and community made in recent years.
Why it matters
The policy sits in section 0 of the district's policy manual as a high‑level statement of district values and informs procedures, school climate habits, and expectations for staff conduct. Community members and several trustees said removing explicit references to protected characteristics would signal a withdrawal from commitments to protect students who face bias and harassment. Administrators said the proposed changes are intended to align district language with the New York State culturally responsive sustaining educational framework and to ensure sustainability over time; trustees asked for further legal review and a return to the policy committee to consider amendments and community feedback.
Next steps
Trustee Wise asked that the policy be retained and revisited; the president said the item will return to the policy committee and that additional legal advice can be sought in executive session. The board scheduled further review and invited public comment ahead of any final vote.
Provenance: Public comments and board discussion on the policy are recorded in the April 8 meeting minutes and video, where speakers identified above made the quoted arguments.
