Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Occ Adjudications topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
OCC reports multiple sustained findings; debate over plainclothes traffic stops and discipline
Summary
The Office of Citizen Complaints reported several sustained findings for June–July cases, including neglect of duty and failure to collect traffic-stop data. Director Hicks and the chief disagreed over whether plainclothes stops were constitutional detentions or policy violations; commissioners asked for policy clarification and training recommendations.
The Office of Citizen Complaints presented adjudication results and statistical updates to the Police Commission Aug. 19, reporting multiple sustained findings in June and July that led primarily to admonishments and retraining.
Director Joyce Hicks summarized cases she said were sustained by the OCC: officers who failed to prepare incident reports after declining private-person arrest requests (written reprimand and retraining), wrongful towing due to transposed license plate numbers (admonishment and retraining), and plainclothes officers making traffic stops without calling marked backup units or collecting required traffic-stop data. Director Hicks said the OCC sustained allegations including neglect of duty, unlawful detention and filing false charges in some cases and recommended training and policy attention.
Chief Sur said the detentions themselves were supported by reasonable suspicion but acknowledged the stops were outside departmental policy — in particular, plainclothes officers should not make traffic stops and should instead summon a marked unit. "They're not supposed to make the traffic stop on the bicycle," the chief said, while adding that the officers in the cases had reasonable suspicion. Director Hicks responded that the OCC did not find the stops lawful under policy and urged clearer training and consequences.
Commissioners asked the OCC to flag themes in the quarterly recommendations so the commission and department can address training and policy changes. Several commissioners stressed the need for clearer policy teeth and consistent consequences for violations.
Formal outcomes: the OCC reported written reprimands and retraining in the described cases; the chief did not concur with some additional sustained allegations in at least one case, which the OCC noted in its report.
Provenance: the OCC's June–July adjudication summary and the ensuing exchange about plainclothes stops appear in the commission packet and in Director Hicks' oral report at the Aug. 19 meeting.
