Police Commission elects new president and vice president after debate over inclusiveness

The San Francisco Police Commission elected new officers at its Nov. 10 meeting, choosing Commissioner Thomas Mazuko as president and Dr. Marshall as vice president after extended discussion about leadership qualities, diversity and inclusiveness.

Commissioner Marshall formally nominated Thomas Mazuko for president, and a number of commissioners spoke in favor, citing meeting‑management skills and knowledge of commission processes. Several commissioners and public commenters urged that leadership reflect gender balance and the commission’s broader political and community representation.

Public commenter Ray Hartz objected to Mazuko’s selection, citing previous interruptions of public speakers and arguing that electing him could discourage participation. Commissioners and the nominee spoke to unity and inclusiveness: Mazuko pledged to involve all commissioners and to emphasize communication. The roll call vote elected Mazuko president, 7–0.

For vice president, Commissioner Angela Chan and Dr. Marshall were nominated. After discussion and public comment, the commission voted 4–3 to elect Dr. Marshall as vice president. Commissioners emphasized that the president and vice president are "first among equals" and reiterated an intent to improve communication with the public and among commissioners.

The commission then announced the new leadership and proceeded with further agenda items.