Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Commuter Shuttles topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
SFMTA board defers plan to funnel commuter shuttles onto Dolores Street after residents' protests
Summary
Residents and Supervisor Scott Wiener urged the SFMTA to stop 'funneling' dozens of commuter shuttles onto Dolores Street, prompting the board to approve some stop relocations while deferring two items affecting Dolores and Oak so staff can study alternatives, including lifting a 3‑ton restriction on Guerrero Street.
Supervisor Scott Wiener told the SFMTA Board on Tuesday that recent changes to commuter‑shuttle rules risk concentrating heavy shuttle traffic on narrow residential corridors. “What ends up happening is funneling,” Wiener said, urging officials not to route “55 shuttles traveling down your street, during a morning rush hour” (Supervisor Scott Wiener). Residents and merchants from Noe Valley, the Panhandle and the Sunset described safety, noise and driveway‑access problems they say would result from the proposed stops.
Board and staff described technical and legal constraints that shaped the plan. Tom McGuire, Sustainable Streets director, said the one‑year pilot requires shuttles to operate only on arterial streets, which narrowed the pool of options and pushed activity toward Dolores and Valencia. He noted Guerrero Street is also an arterial but carries a 3‑ton weight restriction that currently blocks shuttle use there.
SFMTA staff and shuttle program manager Carly Payne defended the agency’s effort to move shuttle activity off small streets and onto arterials, but acknowledged that enforcement and stop placement remain a work in progress. Payne said the agency estimated the aggregate number of shuttle loading events at proposed Dolores locations based on pilot data, but that the figure could vary by operator and stop.
After hours of public comment—residents presented a petition of more than 600 signatures—board members weighed safety, legal limits and the urgency of compliance with the arterial rule. Vice‑Chair Cheryl Brinkman said she supported moving the program forward but urged staff to reduce the burden on any single street. Several board members pressed staff to analyze whether Guerrero’s 3‑ton restriction could be lifted quickly to allow more even distribution of stops.
The Board voted to approve some shuttle stop relocations (items P and Q) while continuing items tied to Dolores and Oak (items J and K) so staff can return with engineering guidance and stakeholder outreach. Staff said an engineering review of Guerrero could be completed in a few weeks, though a full change to lift the weight restriction and hold additional public hearings could take several months.
Next steps: SFMTA staff will study Guerrero Street’s feasibility for shuttle use, conduct targeted outreach to Guerrero stakeholders, and report back to the board. If the weight restriction can be lifted without a “fatal flaw,” staff said some shuttle activity could be reallocated off Dolores within the program’s near‑term implementation timeline.
