Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the San Francisco Eagle Landmark topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Historic Preservation Commission recommends landmark designation for San Francisco Eagle Bar
Summary
The commission unanimously recommended landmark designation for the San Francisco Eagle Bar, citing its four-decade history as a leather and LGBTQ cultural institution, fundraising role during the AIDS crisis, community support and research findings under planning code criteria.
The San Francisco Historic Preservation Commission voted unanimously on May 19 to recommend landmark designation for the San Francisco Eagle Bar, a long-running LGBTQ and leather-culture venue in Western SoMa.
Honey Mahogany, speaking for Supervisor Matt Haney's office, said the Eagle “is a historic nightlife institution and legacy business located in the SoMa Leather And LGBTQ Cultural District,” and noted the nomination was initiated under planning code section 1004.1. Planning staff (Alex Westhoff) presented research documenting the Eagle's role as a community anchor since 1981, including fundraising during the AIDS epidemic, oral-history interviews, and 11 letters of support; staff concluded the property meets two priority criteria (events and people) and recommended the commission forward the designation to the Board of Supervisors.
Public commenters including representatives of the Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District, the GLBT Historical Society, the Office of Small Business and the bar’s owner, Lex Montiel, expressed support. Bob Goldfarb, president of the Leather and LGBTQ Cultural District, testified to his long history attending events at the Eagle and urged the commission to vote for landmark status.
Commissioners asked staff about outreach to the property owner and character-defining features; Alex Westhoff said the department attempted mail and email outreach to the assessor-listed owner/estate and that the leather flag on the roof flagpole was identified as a character-defining feature in the nomination. After discussion and a friendly amendment request to emphasize social and racial equity in the resolution language, a motion to recommend landmark designation was moved, seconded and carried unanimously, 7 to 0. The commission’s recommendation will be forwarded to the Board of Supervisors.
Why it matters Designating the Eagle as a landmark recognizes and preserves a venue that community witnesses and researchers say was central to LGBTQ organizing and fundraising in the city, particularly during the AIDS crisis, and that continues to serve as a cultural and performance space for the neighborhood.
(Article based on planning staff presentation, public comment, and formal commission action recorded in the hearing transcript.)
