Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Parks And Recreation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Preservation commission pauses decision on Golden Gate Park SkyWheel extension, schedules follow-up hearing
Summary
After hours of public testimony both for and against the temporary Sky/observation wheel in Golden Gate Park’s Music Concourse, the commission continued the certificate‑of‑appropriateness matter to March 3 to give supervisors and Recreation & Parks more time to address concerns about lights, generator noise and wildlife impacts.
The San Francisco Historic Preservation Commission on Feb. 17 voted unanimously to continue consideration of an extension request for the temporary observation (Sky) Wheel in Golden Gate Park’s Music Concourse to a March 3 hearing, after receiving extensive presentations from Rec and Park staff and more than a hundred public comments both supporting and opposing the extension.
Michelle Taylor of the Planning Department summarized the case history: the wheel had been approved as a temporary installation in January 2020 and was slated for removal in March 2021. Because the attraction operated only sporadically during the pandemic, Recreation & Parks requested an operational extension—up to four years—to offset vendor hardship and to support the department’s stated recovery objectives.
Dana Ketchum, Recreation & Parks director of property management, told commissioners the wheel provides economic activation, free‑ticket programs for underserved families and a COVID‑safe outdoor attraction. Ketchum described mitigation steps already implemented and planned: limiting light shows late at night, programming to shut down diesel generators overnight with battery backup for safety lights, aesthetic improvements to fencing and a longer‑term effort to bring permanent electrical service to the concourse.
Supervisor Hillary Ronen? (Transcript: Supervisor Chan; District 1 Supervisor) — speaking for District 1 — asked the commission to consider a continuance so she and her colleagues could work with Rec and Park and constituent groups to refine the duration and conditions of any extension.
Public comment ran nearly three hours and represented a wide cross section of opinion. Supporters—business groups, concession operators, neighborhood residents and nonprofits—said the wheel has brought visitors and income to nearby legacy businesses, provided tens of thousands of free tickets to underserved families and offered a safe outdoor activity during the pandemic. Rodney Fung, president of the San Francisco Chamber of Commerce, urged approval for economic recovery reasons.
Opponents—environmental advocates, nearby residents and nature organizations including the Sierra Club and Golden Gate Audubon—urged denial or a much shorter extension. They raised concerns about light pollution, adverse impacts on birds and bats, diesel generator noise and exhaust, the historic integrity of the Music Concourse landscape and the absence of a full environmental review under CEQA.
Commissioners debated options including a short continuance to permit supervisors and Rec and Park to reconcile conditions, a limited interim extension while improvements were implemented, or full approval for the requested multi‑year term. Out of deference to supervisors’ requests for additional review and to allow Rec and Park more time to produce firm mitigation and electrification plans, the commission continued the item to March 3, 2021, by unanimous vote 6–0.
Next steps: Rec and Park will continue outreach and provide a more detailed mitigation and electrification schedule to the commission; the matter will return for a March 3 hearing where commissioners expect updated operational details and responses to environmental and public‑health concerns.
Sources: Planning Department and Recreation & Parks presentations and public testimony to the San Francisco Historic Preservation Commission, Feb. 17, 2021.
