Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Historic Designation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Preservation panel declines to change historic status of 235 Valencia Street after heated testimony
Summary
After extensive public testimony for and against reclassification, the Preservation Commission declined to amend the Intermission North Historic Resource Survey status code for 235 Valencia Street; a motion to amend failed by roll call (4–0 no). Proponents had argued the building’s association with Hap Jones merits reclassification; owners urged commemoration via a 'Living Alley' and warned designation would trigger an EIR and delay.
The Preservation Commission on Oct. 19 considered whether to change the California Historical Resources status code for 235 Valencia Street following a community‑sponsored Article 10 landmark nomination and prior hearings.
Shannon Ferguson of the Planning Department reminded the commission that the item before them was whether the property met eligibility under Criterion B for association with Hap Jones and whether it retained integrity to warrant a status‑code change. "At that time, the property was given a status code of 6L or determined ineligible for a local listing ... but may warrant special consideration in local planning," Ferguson said.
Members of the public and preservation advocates made opposing cases. Kelly Hill, a long‑time neighborhood resident and proponent, said the site represents the "last unaltered early motorcycle dealership in the city," documenting years of association with Hap Jones and the motorcycle industry. Mike Bueller of San Francisco Heritage urged reclassification to ensure future design review, saying the issue "raises important questions about the role of the HPC, what is worth preserving in San Francisco today, and the adequacy and fairness of the city's environmental review process."
The property owner and project team urged the commission not to change the survey. Craig Hamburg (DDG) told the commission the sponsor would "redevelop the site and commemorate motorcycle culture and Hap Jones via Living Alley," and warned that formal historic designation would trigger an EIR and a lengthy review process. He also said Hap Jones' association with the property was limited to 1940–1959 and that other sites in the corridor may better represent motorcycle history.
Following procedural discussion about outstanding prior motions, the commission called and acted on a motion to amend the Intermission North Historic Resource Survey findings for 235 Valencia. On roll call the votes were recorded as No, No, No, No and the motion to amend the findings failed (4–0). There was no alternate motion to change the status; the item was closed without a change to the survey.
Speakers on both sides emphasized preservation of cultural memory; proponents asked the commission to use reclassification to bring the project back for review, while the owner said commemoration outside of a landmark designation would be pursued.
The commission did not make a finding changing the status code on Oct. 19; staff and advocates may continue outreach and design discussions outside the HPC action.
