Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Parks topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves Alamo Square Park renovation, including an ADA restroom and irrigation upgrades
Summary
The Historic Preservation Commission unanimously approved a certificate of appropriateness for Alamo Square Park renovations on June 4, 2014, covering a new ADA-accessible unisex restroom, landscape improvements and a replacement irrigation system intended to cut water use by about one-third; commissioners attached conditions and staff will return with final details.
The San Francisco Historic Preservation Commission voted unanimously on June 4 to approve a certificate of appropriateness for a renovation of Alamo Square Park that includes a new ADA‑accessible unisex restroom near the playground, landscape upgrades and replacement of the park’s aging irrigation system.
Shelly Caldigirone introduced the item and explained staff’s support for the design with one condition on reconstruction of removed or altered historical features in a historically accurate manner. Mary Hobson, project manager for the Recreation and Parks Department, presented the design: a low‑profile poured‑concrete restroom set into the hillside, powder‑coated grills for ventilation, a single locked gated entry configuration, a janitor’s closet, and landscape improvements intended to retain the majority of open lawns and to replace the irrigation system to reduce water usage by roughly one‑third.
Hobson said staff evaluated renovating and expanding the existing historic restroom but that doing so would have triggered extensive accessible‑path‑of‑travel code requirements, requiring hundreds of linear feet of ramps through mature tree stands or rerouting historic pathways; the proposed new facility was presented as a compromise to achieve accessibility with fewer impacts.
Members of the public both opposed and supported the project. Several residents said they worried about tree removal, loss of the park’s informal play character, the look of proposed ‘no‑mow’ planting and construction disruption; one speaker questioned why tax dollars were not used to renovate the existing facility. Supporters and representatives of the Alamo Square Neighborhood Association said tree health and failing plantings require intervention and urged restoration to the park’s historic character.
After discussion and responses from staff clarifying materials and accessibility tradeoffs, a motion to approve the project with conditions was made and seconded. The commission voted 7–0 in roll call to approve. Staff will return with final materials and a draft letter where required and implement the one stated condition to reconstruct altered historic elements in a historically accurate manner.
