Citizen Portal
Sign In

Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!

Get email alerts on the Family Shelter Policy topic

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Advocates urge delay as HSH plans new family shelter eligibility, shorter stays

San Francisco Homelessness and Oversight Commission · December 5, 2024
AI-Generated Content: All content on this page was generated by AI to highlight key points from the meeting. For complete details and context, we recommend watching the full video. so we can fix them.

Summary

HSH proposed reinstating 14‑day and 90‑day lengths of stay with capped extensions and tightening family wait‑list eligibility, prompting providers and advocates to warn the changes could push families back to the street and request more time for community input.

Chief Deputy Marian Sanders presented nearly year‑long stakeholder work to reform the family shelter system, proposing three linked changes: reinstating explicit length‑of‑stay limits (14 days for urgent accommodation placements; 90 days for other family programs), permitting up to three provider‑approved extensions and referral to HSH for further review, and tightening family wait‑list eligibility so many doubled‑up or SRO households would not qualify unless imminent eviction or other narrowly defined criteria apply.

HSH said the 90‑day standard was community‑driven after providers rejected a 180‑day approach during workshops and that the new policy would reduce the family wait list by an estimated 52% based on November data. Sanders said families eligible for extensions must be actively engaged in case management, have a family success plan, and that undocumented families unable to resolve barriers would be explicitly considered for extensions in revised language before the Dec. 10 effective date.

Public commenters—including HESPA, Coalition on Homelessness, Glide and multiple service providers—strongly opposed parts of the proposal. They argued the changes do not reflect the realities of limited affordable housing, undercount the vulnerabilities of doubled‑up families and transitional age youth, and risk returning families to unsafe conditions. Advocates asked HSH to delay implementation, expand extension criteria, and preserve wait‑list access for doubled‑up and SRO households to avoid destabilizing children and caregivers.

Commissioners pressed HSH on timing and evaluation: staff said the length‑of‑stay clock begins Dec. 10, new Safer Families Rapid Rehousing slots are expected in March, and HSH will evaluate the policy’s effects by the end of FY25 with provider and lived‑experience input. Commissioners recommended clearer communications to families, trauma‑informed outreach ahead of any notices, and program‑level reporting on how many families are on housing referral tracks versus problem‑solving pathways.