Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Neighborhood Noise Casa Sanchez topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves Casa Sanchez indoor music permit after heated neighborhood debate
Summary
After extended testimony from neighbors and supporters the Entertainment Commission approved Casa Sanchez’s limited live-performance permit for interior-only music, applying the Good Neighbor Policy and excluding several Mission Station security conditions; commissioners stressed that amplified or outdoor entertainment would require separate permits.
The Entertainment Commission approved a limited live-performance permit for Casa Sanchez on Jan. 10 after an extended, sometimes emotional public hearing that split neighbors and supporters.
Owner Martha Sanchez told commissioners that Casa Sanchez is a five-generation Mission District institution that has hosted community events for decades and that the proposed live performances would be small-scale and often daytime. "My grandfather came here in 1923 with a tortilla press tucked under his arm," Sanchez said, framing the application in family and cultural terms.
Neighbors including Frank Duarte and Marie Sorensen described years of disruptive outdoor and backyard music, with Duarte saying he had measured peak inside his home and reported repeated police calls. Others testified that loud music outside — including boom boxes and patio events — has prevented routine use of backyards and disrupted sleep. Some neighbors asked the commission to deny the permit.
Staff read written recommendations from Captain Greg Corrales of Mission Police Station asking that events be limited to the interior, that at least one security guard be present per a stated ratio of patrons, that security remain after events to patrol nearby streets, and that permits be suspended at an officer’s direction if noise complaints continued.
Commissioners debated whether to include the Mission Station's specified security and perimeter patrol conditions. Commissioner Hyde moved to approve an interior-only limited live permit with the Good Neighbor Policy as a condition but to exclude those specific Mission Station patrol and suspension conditions; the motion passed on recorded vote.
The commission emphasized that interior-only permits require doors and windows to be closed during performances, that outdoor amplified entertainment (or boom boxes) would require separate loudspeaker or outdoor permits, and that neighbors must be provided a contact number so staff or the licensee can respond quickly to complaints. Staff and police retained authority to enforce compliance and to suspend privileges in the event of ongoing violations.
Next steps: Casa Sanchez must comply with the Good Neighbor Policy and building/fire-code requirements and will be subject to enforcement if sound is audible beyond the premises or if neighbors report noncompliance.
