Commission approves conditional transfer of Shine permit at 1337 Mission
Loading...
Summary
The San Francisco Entertainment Commission voted unanimously to approve a conditional replacement-tenant permit for 1337 Mission (Shine). Commissioners pressed applicants on nightclub-management experience and neighborhood outreach; staff required security conditions including a front-door camera.
The San Francisco Entertainment Commission on Tuesday unanimously approved a conditional replacement-tenant permit allowing new operators to run Shine at 1337 Mission Street.
Commissioners said they were persuaded by the applicant’s security plan, written neighborhood support in the packet and the security company contracted to the venue, but several members warned that running a nightclub requires specific floor-management experience. "I have deep concerns about people who have no experience," said Commissioner Joseph, who pressed the applicants on prior roles at the Avalon and the Vanguard and on how they would handle disputes and problem patrons.
Applicants and their representative told commissioners they selected Shine because of its "seemingly good operation and clientele," and that they would retain current employees while JT Culler would serve as general manager. "We completely understand what's at stake," the applicant said, adding she had studied the business for more than a year and would be hands-on in management.
Staff said the Southern Police Station asked that the front-door security camera be upgraded as a condition of approval; the applicants agreed to the camera and to the other recommended conditions. Staff also noted letters of support from neighbors are included in the application packet and that at least one resident emailed the office to say they met the new owners and supported the purchase.
A motion to approve the replacement-tenant permit was made and seconded; a roll call showed votes of "Aye" from Commissioner Cavallini, Mister Conetti, Mister Nico, Commissioner Joseph and President Noland. The motion passed, and staff and commissioners offered the applicants assistance if problems arise.
The permit approval is conditional on the items laid out in the staff recommendation, including the security measures. The applicants were advised to maintain neighborhood outreach and follow the conditions to avoid future enforcement actions.
