Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Personnel Discipline topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Fire Commission approves findings in employee discipline case, limits disclosure to HR
Summary
After a closed session on Case No. 2016‑03, the Fire Commission voted to approve proposed findings of fact, moved not to disclose its deliberations, and authorized disclosure of transcripts, evidence and the findings to Human Resources for a civil service appeal.
The San Francisco Fire Commission went into closed session April 12 to deliberate proposed findings of fact in Case No. 2016‑03, an employee discipline matter. The Commission cited Government Code and San Francisco Administrative Code provisions permitting closed‑session deliberation on personnel matters.
After returning to open session at 11:54 a.m., the City Attorney disclosed that the Commission had voted to approve the findings of fact in the case. The Commission then voted unanimously to withhold disclosure of its closed‑session deliberations. Separately, the Commission approved a motion to disclose the closed‑session transcripts and evidence (but not the Commission's deliberations) and the findings of fact to Human Resources representatives for the limited purpose of a civil service appeal.
The Commission's action preserves internal deliberative material while enabling the employee's administrative appeal process to proceed with access to evidence and the formal findings. The meeting record does not disclose the substance of the findings or the identity of the employee; counsel and the Commission cited applicable closed‑session exemptions in state and local law.
