Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Esr Bonds topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Officials report progress and budget pressures on earthquake-safety and public-safety facility projects
Summary
Program managers told the committee that ESR bond projects have delivered cisterns, new fire-station steel, and a functioning medical examiner facility, but cited market pressures, a major police facility budget gap reduced by value engineering and ongoing questions about capital-versus-maintenance uses of bond funds.
City program managers presented an update on the city's 2010 and 2014 Earthquake Safety and Emergency Response (ESR) bond programs, flagging substantial project completions alongside budgetary and implementation risks.
Charles Agueras, senior project and program manager, said the city completed 30 committed cisterns to improve the Auxiliary Water Supply System and finished key elements of public-safety buildings; the Medical Examiner facility is operational and received its final completion certificate in March. Project managers reported progress on neighborhood fire stations (Fire Station 16 tracking to a September completion; Fire Station 5 scheduled for December) and noted design-permit tasks for Fire Station 35 are underway.
Police facilities work includes demolition at the Evans site and a construction-delivery approach that produced an early $30 million overrun estimate for a new facility; after value engineering the overage was reduced to under $7 million and the capital planning committee agreed to accommodate the remaining amount in next year's budget package rather than a supplemental appropriation. Project managers said the city is pursuing cost reconciliation and value engineering to close gaps.
Commissioners and staff also debated the appropriate use of bond funds for projects such as shower renovations and roof work. Committee members questioned whether some contracts resemble routine maintenance; Public Works and program staff responded that bond-funded work must be capital in nature with a useful life of 25+ years and that projects are screened with the public finance office and City Attorney to ensure compliance.
Operational concerns about traffic and emergency response were raised; Assistant Deputy Chief Anthony Rivera said traffic congestion on the Embarcadero and increased activity around stations can slow responses and described workarounds, including lane closures coordinated with PD and, when needed, driving on streetcar tracks to respond faster. Staff said they coordinate with MTA and Public Works on siting and response-time analysis.
The committee requested continued updates on budget reconciliations and agreed to follow up on the boundary between capital projects and maintenance.
