Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Pac Appointment topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Heated public debate over PAC appointment forces SFUSD to delay nomination
Summary
The Parent Advisory Council’s unanimous nomination of Seth Brenzel touched off hours of public testimony and board questioning about representation and recruitment. Commissioners asked PAC to return with a more diverse slate; the appointment was deferred.
The San Francisco Board of Education deferred a Parent Advisory Council appointment after a long public comment period that exposed deep concerns about the council’s racial, linguistic and neighborhood representation.
Michelle Jacques Menegas, PAC coordinator, presented the PAC’s recommendation to appoint Seth Brenzel to a regular PAC seat for a two‑year term beginning Feb. 1, 2021. PAC members told the board they had voted unanimously to recommend Brenzel after interviews by PAC members.
Public comment stretched for more than an hour with dozens of callers both supporting and opposing the nomination. Supporters — including PTO leaders and parents who said Brenzel is an active volunteer and one of few prospective male and LGBTQ candidates — said rejecting him for his associations would set a dangerous political precedent. Detractors, including leaders of several community groups and PAC critics, argued the PAC underrepresents Asian, Southeast Asian, Filipino, Native American and other language communities and that the board should insist on a more diverse slate of candidates instead of approving a single appointment.
Several commissioners asked PAC to return with a more representative group of nominees. Commissioner Sanchez said he would prefer the PAC present a slate that demonstrates the council as a whole is becoming more inclusive. Legal counsel advised deferring the vote rather than attempting to act after a heated public debate; the board voted to defer the appointment and asked staff and PAC leadership to expand recruitment and return with additional candidates.
The exchange exposed long‑standing grievances about which constituencies are heard by the district and highlighted calls for paid stipends or other supports to remove barriers to participation for lower‑income parents and monolingual families. PAC leadership said recruitment was disrupted by the pandemic and pledged intensified outreach and follow‑up with underserved communities.
Next steps: The board asked PAC and staff to return with a more diverse slate of nominees and an outreach plan; the vote on the recommended candidate was postponed. The board also discussed options to support recruitment, including possible stipends or targeted outreach to under‑represented neighborhoods and languages.
