Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Serve Program topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
SF school board directs staff to develop ‘SERVE’ emergency-response curriculum after heated JROTC debate
Summary
After hours of public testimony from students, alumni and parents defending Junior Reserve Officer Training Corps (JROTC), the San Francisco Unified School District board voted to ask the superintendent to develop a new Student Emergency Response Volunteers (SERVE) leadership curriculum and return implementation cost estimates to the budget committee within three months.
The San Francisco Unified School District board voted to ask the superintendent to develop a student leadership curriculum called SERVE (Student Emergency Response Volunteers), which would train students in emergency preparedness, advanced first aid and community outreach.
The decision came after an extended public-comment period in which dozens of students, parents, alumni and community members urged the board to retain the district's JROTC program and criticized framing SERVE as a replacement. Students and alumni described JROTC's role teaching CPR, first aid and leadership and gave concrete examples of cadets assisting in emergencies and registering residents for the Neighborhood Emergency Response Team (NERT).
Superintendent Garcia and several board members framed the resolution narrowly as a request to develop curriculum rather than implement a systemwide program immediately. Commissioner Kim, who authored the resolution, said the board's action is meant to create and test a leadership elective and club that would cover NERT training, CPR/AED, ham-radio communications and disaster-response skills. The budget committee asked that once a draft curriculum is ready, staff return with implementation cost estimates for a budget committee review within three months.
Opponents of treating SERVE as a replacement stressed that SERVE, as described, appears shorter and less comprehensive than four-year JROTC courses. Student speakers including battalion leaders and cadets told the board SERVE "cannot replace this 90-year-old program," arguing JROTC offers sustained leadership development, peer mentorship and community connections. University and emergency-medicine witnesses urged alignment with the city's emergency plans and routing any training through the Department of Emergency Management and the city's disaster council.
Commissioner Winslow pressed staff for a fuller fiscal and programmatic analysis, noting the district's task-force work and existing partnerships (for example, Health Academy programs and past school-site pilots) that could inform curriculum design. In response, supporters said the board is voting only to develop a curriculum and explore leveraging federal, state and city emergency-preparedness funding before implementation.
The board approved the request to develop a SERVE curriculum by roll call (6 ayes). The motion specified school-site placement decisions, implementation funding and program scope must be handled separately; implementation will return to the budget committee for review.
What happens next: Staff will draft the SERVE curriculum elements and return with an implementation cost estimate and recommended school-site placement process for budget-committee review within three months.
