Planning Commission clears CEQA and downtown authorizations for 10 South Van Ness tower, including land-dedication option for affordable housing
Loading...
Summary
The commission adopted CEQA findings, shadow findings and downtown project authorization for a proposed 55-story, 966-unit tower at 10 South Van Ness; the developer proposed a land-dedication option that could yield an equivalent of roughly 35% affordable units, and agreed to an on-site interpretive exhibit commemorating Fillmore/Fillmore West.
The Planning Commission on June 11 adopted environmental and project approvals for a proposed 55-story mixed-use tower at 10 South Van Ness Avenue that would add about 966 housing units adjacent to downtown transit and include a privately owned public open space and a proposed in-building entrance to the Van Ness Muni station.
The project sponsor proposed to meet inclusionary requirements through a land-dedication alternative under Planning Code Section 249.33(b)(16) that would dedicate a site for affordable housing with the objective of accommodating an amount equivalent to 35% of the project's units; the sponsorship team said the dedicated site would need MOHCD acceptance and Board of Supervisors action. Staff reported a memorandum-to-file that the land-dedication option would not materially change the impacts identified in the certified final EIR.
Commission debate focused on the suite of exceptions requested through the downtown project authorization: dwelling-unit exposure, sunlight access, wind and podium/tower massing consistent with the Hub plan, and a wider mid-block passage. Staff and the sponsor said the design increased sidewalk and public-realm amenities, provided roughly 40,000 sq. ft. of resident open space and 9,000 sq. ft. of community/affordable retail, and included sustainability commitments (certified LEED Gold and carbon-neutral certification).
Commission votes were recorded on a series of discrete motions: adoption of CEQA findings (passed 6'to—), shadow findings, downtown project authorization (passed 6'to—), and conditional use authorizations. Two commissioners recorded no votes on some items; the final votes approved CEQA findings and the downtown authorization with conditions. Staff noted the project sponsor would also contribute significant in-lieu fees (approx. $17 million) and that the dedicated land site would require subsequent MOHCD and Board of Supervisors sign-off.
Supporters emphasized the project's location at a high-transit node and potential to produce housing and construction jobs; critics raised concerns about added parking, loading operations along Twelfth Street, and the hub area's equity framework. The commission approved the requested actions with conditions and directed staff and the sponsor to finalize land-dedication arrangements and CEQA mitigation tracking.
