Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Housing Development topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning Commission approves 1043–1045 Clayton St. CUA with balcony setback
Summary
The Planning Commission approved a conditional use authorization to convert three lots at 1043–1045 Clayton Street into three duplexes (six units total), imposing a condition to pull second-floor balconies 3 feet off the southern property lines to reduce privacy impacts; the vote was unanimous.
The San Francisco Planning Commission on May 7 approved a conditional use authorization to reconfigure 1043–1045 Clayton Street in the Buena Vista neighborhood, allowing the consolidation of three lots and construction of three duplex buildings that would create six dwelling units — a net gain of four homes.
Planning Department staff told commissioners the project complies with Planning Code sections 303 and 317 and recommended approval after receiving seven letters of support and six letters of opposition. Planner Sylvia Jimenez said the department finds the project consistent with general-plan objectives and neighborhood character and that the required notice and pre-application procedures were completed in 2018.
Jeremy Shaw of Lee Architects, representing the sponsors, described the design as consolidating an existing two-unit building across three lots into a compliant single-lot configuration and adding two new two-unit buildings on the adjacent lots. Shaw said the scheme provides six family-sized units, six off-street parking spaces and six Class 1 bicycle spaces, requires no waivers and would not demolish any pre-1970 qualifying units.
Neighbors who spoke during the public-comment period urged a continuance and raised three principal concerns: (1) that mailed notices and plan postings arrived late or were difficult to access during the shelter-in-place period; (2) potential loss of light and privacy to downhill properties because parts of the proposed building will be taller than adjacent homes; and (3) drainage and geotechnical impacts on steep slopes. Several supporters called for approval, saying the city needs more housing and that the design is compatible with the street.
Commissioners pressed staff about noticing and displacement risk. Jimenez said the pre-application meeting and adjacent-notice requirements occurred in 2018 and an eviction-history check dating back ten years showed no records for the property. Staff also said geotechnical and construction-stage drainage oversight are handled through the Department of Building Inspection as part of later permit review.
After deliberation, Commissioner Diamond moved to approve the conditional use authorization with a condition requiring all three second-floor balconies that sit on the southern lot lines to be pulled back three feet; the motion was seconded and approved unanimously. The commission recorded the vote as in favor and imposed the balcony-offset condition to address privacy concerns. The project will proceed to final permit review and any DBI-required construction safeguards.
