Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the 1196 Columbus Hotel topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission deadlocks on North Beach hotel; matter continued until Nov.16
Summary
The Commission split on whether to approve a revised 4‑story AC Hotel (Marriott) at 1196 Columbus Avenue after neighbors raised land‑use and neighborhood‑character concerns; motions to approve and to deny both failed ties, and the Commission continued consideration to Nov. 16 for further review and design refinement.
The Planning Commission spent substantial time debating a revised 75‑room hotel proposal at 1196 Columbus Avenue that the project team reworked after earlier neighborhood objections. Staff outlined design changes including elimination of a rooftop deck and bar/lounge, revised storefronts, and a change in brand to AC Hotels by Marriott; the project team said the owner had agreed to union construction terms and a number of design revisions intended to reduce impacts on immediate neighbors.
Opponents — including the North Beach Tenants Committee and Telegraph Hill Dwellers — argued the site is primarily residential and should be used for housing rather than hotel rooms, raising concerns about noise, children at nearby preschools and the loss of neighborhood character. Labor and travel organizations supported the project for job creation and to add hotel capacity in the city.
The Commission first tied 3–3 on a motion to approve the revised project, and subsequent motions to continue with design direction or to disapprove likewise produced tie votes. To break the impasse, Commissioner Moore moved to continue the item until a meeting with a full commission could be held on Nov. 16; that motion passed unanimously 6–0 at the next roll call after scheduling adjustments.
Ending: With public comment and design debate extensive, the Commission chose to delay the final decision until a fuller set of materials and a full commission presence on Nov. 16.
