Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Urban Design Guidelines topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
San Francisco planning debate intensifies over proposed citywide Urban Design Guidelines
Summary
Neighbors, preservation groups and commissioners clashed Thursday over city staff raft Urban Design Guidelines, with critics urging stronger neighborhood protections, transparency and elimination of a proposed "waiver" mechanism while staff defended the need for a consistent citywide framework.
San Francisco—ommissioners and dozens of public commenters spent the bulk of the commission—alendar Thursday debating proposed citywide Urban Design Guidelines and how they would be applied across neighborhoods.
Planning Department staff presented the 23-guideline framework as an attempt to unify fragmented rules and provide a common language for project review, saying the UDGs would apply in neighborhood commercial and mixed-use areas while leaving residential design guidelines in place. "They are intended to reinforce existing policy and help create consistency in design review," staff representative Maya Small told the commission.
Opponents, including the Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods, Telegraph Hill Dwellers and multiple neighborhood associations, said the draft still contains substantive changes and could supplant community-specific rules. "The guideline process has lacked meaningful outreach," said George Whiting of the Coalition for San Francisco Neighborhoods. Critics repeatedly urged the commission to remove a provision that would allow limited waivers to individual guidelines at the commission level, calling it a loophole that could erode neighborhood protections.
Supporters said a citywide set of standards is necessary for larger projects and for consistency across different review bodies. Commissioner Johnson argued the guidelines would give the commission a clearer basis to judge large proposals in rapidly changing areas such as eastern neighborhoods and Potrero Hill.
Staff said they will continue outreach, publish a cross-reference matrix mapping the UDGs to existing area-specific guidance and expand examples that show how older buildings nd neighborhood character can be preserved. Commissioners asked staff to return with clearer implementation procedures and proposed case studies showing how the guidelines would have applied to recent contentious projects. The commission did not take a final vote Thursday; staff said the draft will return after revised outreach and specification of implementation steps.
