Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Development Project topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission Approves Vertical Addition at 1452–1458 Broadway with Conditions to Reduce Park Shadowing and Improve Design
Summary
The commission approved a vertical addition atop an existing two‑story commercial building at 1452–1458 Broadway with increased upper‑floor setbacks to avoid casting new shadows on the Helen Wills Park recreation courts, design refinements for privacy glazing and instructions for staff to pursue an eighth unit if code and egress allow.
The Planning Commission approved a proposal to add four stories to an existing two‑story building at 1452–1458 Broadway, creating seven dwelling units while retaining ground‑floor parking.
Architects revised the design after a shadow analysis showed the original proposal could increase shading on the Helen Wills Park courts. The revised plan introduced upper‑floor front and rear setbacks (including a 24‑foot/51‑foot stepback at upper floors) to prevent new shadows on the park and to minimize impacts on the public open space. The sponsor also proposed streetscape improvements, a reduced curb cut and new street trees.
Neighbors raised concerns about shadows and daylight impacts on a rear courtyard and adjacent apartments; the applicant agreed to refined privacy measures including frosted glazing on some light wells and to work with staff to explore whether an eighth unit could be added without compromising egress or increasing shadows. The commission required the project to substitute roof hatches for private penthouse stair access, to set back the large roof terrace and to pursue modest refinements to unit layout to reduce an oversized top unit's terrace.
The motion to approve passed 4–1, with Commissioner Moore voting against due to outstanding policy concerns about conversions of non‑conforming ground‑floor envelopes to dense residential use.
